Instant Offers — Get Paid Fast
Sell Your Cards to Monmouth Cards
Enter any PSA or BGS cert number for an instant offer. No haggling, no waiting, no fees. Cash or store credit — your choice.
⚡ Instant Offers
💰 Cash or Credit
🛡 No Fees
🏆 No Max Value
🏪 9 Locations
Step 1 — Enter cert number
How It Works
🔍
1. Get an Offer
Enter your cert number. We give you an instant cash and credit offer based on live market data.
📦
2. Ship or Drop Off
Use our free shipping label or visit any of our store locations across NJ, CT & MA.
💰
3. Get Paid
Get Paid Cash via Stripe in 2 days, or instant store credit with a bonus on your payout.
Questions
Yes! We buy graded cards from PSA, BGS, CGC, and SGC across all categories — sports cards (baseball, basketball, football, hockey, soccer), Pokémon, MTG, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and more. We also buy raw cards, sealed boxes, and entire collections in-store at any of our locations.
Our pricing engine pulls real-time market data from recent sales across major marketplaces and dealer networks. We update pricing regularly to ensure you get the most competitive offer available.
Cash payouts via Stripe are processed within 2 business days of card verification. Store credit is applied to your account instantly upon verification. Drop off in-store for same-day processing.
Yes! Bring raw cards to any Monmouth Cards location for an in-person evaluation. Our staff will assess condition and make an offer on the spot.
No maximum. Unlike some competitors who cap payouts, we have no upper limit. We buy cards at any value — from $5 commons to five-figure gems.
Absolutely. If you have a large collection (50+ cards), contact your nearest store or call 551-309-3434 to schedule a private evaluation. We purchase entire collections of any size.